I keep coming back to optionality as the thing I value most when judging what’s good for myself or the world. It’s clear in almost all the writing I’ve done so far: from how great md files are to why we need cypherpunk values and open societies. They all keep pointing back to increasing or protecting optionality.
At some point I just had to write about it directly.
Optionality, at its simplest, is having genuine options open and the ability to take advantage of them. We’re fallible, we can’t predict complex systems perfectly, and we’re inevitably going to make mistakes. And when that happens, we need to be able to change course and self-correct.
Progress (individual or systemic) is easier when we have optionality. Every good thing that’s ever been built or discovered came from someone having the optionality to try something new, get feedback, and adjust. So it’s not about staying put with open options, you need to be moving. Once you do, it compounds: more available options mean more attempts, more feedback, and faster learning, which accelerates progress and creates options you couldn’t see before.
At the personal level, I think of this as “strong opinions loosely held.” People sometimes see that as arrogance. In my opinion is one of the most humble ways one can behave, by accepting that:
-
Things are not perfect and can be improved, so you need to keep moving and trying new stuff out.
-
You are going to make mistakes, so you need to keep an open mind to reverse when that inevitably happens.
This is not against decisiveness or committing to stuff. Decisive action is usually better than endless hedging, and commitments are valuable and deliberately make other options harder. But it wouldn’t be a commitment if there’s no way out of it; you have to keep choosing to do it, and for that to be true you need to have the option to exit.
That exit option matters more than people admit. People are happier when they perceive open options and depressed when they don’t see a way out of something.
At the systems level it means being as horizontal and open as possible, with general rules that don’t push one specific kind of thinking or behavior. Different problems require different types of intelligence, so progress comes from letting diverse people live according to their interests and run their own experiments while keeping the ability to self-correct.
Periods of suffering and lack of progress have historically been tied to a decrease in optionality. This usually happens when a group of people treat a complex system as if it were simple, they think they can predict the future and deliver utopia, so they force society into a closed system where disagreement is punished and people can’t try new things because supposedly they already have the best answer. The answer is obviously incorrect, but course-correction becomes so hard that it’s followed by a long period of suffering.
You can still experiment with extremely rigid systems, as long as they have an exit option, it’s ok. Imagine the amount of suffering that would have been saved if people were able to try a system like communism, realize it doesn’t work and then exit fast. The problem is never trying new kinds of systems or making mistakes, the problem is removing optionality from participants so they can’t self-correct.
So in my opinion, until I change it:
-
capitalism > socialism
-
free speech > censorship
-
crypto > central banks
-
open-source ai > closed ai
-
decentralization > authoritarianism
This is why I keep returning to it. Almost everything I end up caring about shares a common denominator: preserving or increasing optionality.